Emerald vs Tsavorite Garnet
Emerald and tsavorite garnet are the two most sought-after green gemstones in fine jewelry. Both display vivid greens that catch the eye, but they differ in mineral composition, clarity, durability, and price. This guide will help you decide which green gem is right for you.
| Factor | Emerald | Tsavorite Garnet |
|---|
| Mineral | Beryl | Grossular garnet |
| Mohs Hardness | 7.5 – 8 | 7 – 7.5 |
| Clarity | Included (jardin expected) | Typically eye-clean |
| Color | Bluish-green to pure green | Vivid pure green to yellowish-green |
| Treatments | Oil/resin filling (standard) | Untreated (never treated) |
| Price Range | $500 – $50,000+ per carat | $500 – $8,000 per carat |
| Max Size | Available in large sizes | Rare above 3 carats |
| Brilliance | Moderate (step cut typical) | High (excellent light return) |
Color Comparison
Fine emerald displays a slightly bluish green that no other gemstone can match—it has a velvety, rich depth of color that is unmistakable. Tsavorite garnet offers a vivid, pure green that is often brighter and more lively than emerald due to its higher refractive index and the fact that it is typically faceted in brilliant cuts that maximize light return. If you prefer a deep, sophisticated green, emerald wins. If you prefer a bright, sparkling green, tsavorite is outstanding.
Clarity & Treatments
This is where tsavorite has a significant advantage. Emeralds almost always contain visible inclusions (the jardin), and virtually all emeralds are treated with oil or resin to improve their appearance. Tsavorite garnet is never treated and is typically eye-clean, which appeals strongly to buyers who value untreated natural gemstones. For gem purists, tsavorite is the clear winner in this category.
Which Should You Choose?
Choose emerald if: You want the prestige of a precious gemstone, prefer the classic bluish-green color, want larger sizes, or appreciate the history and romance associated with emerald.
Choose tsavorite if: You value untreated natural color, want excellent clarity and brilliance, prefer a more affordable green gemstone, or love bright, vivid greens. Tsavorite is an exceptional engagement ring stone.
Browse our emerald jewelry collection.