Morganite vs Rose Quartz
Morganite and rose quartz are two popular pink gemstones, but they are very different in quality, durability, and value. While rose quartz is widely available and affordable, morganite is a member of the prestigious beryl family and commands significantly higher prices. Here is how they compare.
| Factor | Morganite | Rose Quartz |
|---|
| Mineral | Beryl (sister of emerald) | Quartz |
| Mohs Hardness | 7.5 – 8 | 7 |
| Clarity | Transparent, eye-clean | Translucent to opaque |
| Color | Pastel pink to salmon to rose | Soft, milky pink |
| Brilliance | High (faceted, excellent light return) | Low (typically cabochon cut, hazy) |
| Price Range | $100 – $800 per carat | $2 – $30 per carat |
| Best For | Engagement rings, fine jewelry | Fashion jewelry, beads, carvings |
The Key Difference: Transparency
The most obvious difference is transparency. Morganite is a transparent gemstone that sparkles brilliantly when faceted, just like its beryl cousins emerald and aquamarine. Rose quartz is typically translucent to opaque with a hazy, milky quality that prevents it from being faceted into sparkling gems. Rose quartz is usually cut as cabochons, beads, or carved into decorative objects.
Engagement Ring Suitability
Morganite has become one of the most popular engagement ring gemstones in recent years. Its excellent hardness (7.5–8), transparency, and romantic pink color make it a durable, beautiful choice for daily wear. Rose quartz is not recommended for engagement rings due to its lower clarity, lack of brilliance, and softer appearance.
Which Should You Choose?
Choose morganite if: You want a fine jewelry gemstone with excellent brilliance and durability, especially for rings. Morganite pairs beautifully with rose gold settings.
Choose rose quartz if: You want an affordable pink gemstone for fashion jewelry, beaded bracelets, pendants, or decorative pieces. Rose quartz is lovely for casual and bohemian styles.