Loading...

Curated Gift Collection

Jewelry Gifts Under $500

Make a statement with premium diamond and gold jewelry under $500. This price range unlocks stunning diamond rings, elegant tennis bracelets, and show-stopping earrings crafted to become heirloom pieces.

Shop Gifts Under $500 View All Gift Ideas
Diamond stud earrings gift
Diamond hoop earrings gift
Heart pendant gift
Tennis bracelet gift
★ Family-Owned Since 1999 ✓ Certified Conflict-Free Diamonds ✓ Free Insured Shipping ✓ 30-Day Money-Back Guarantee ★ 222+ Five-Star Google Reviews

Gift Guide

Shop by Category

Diamond stud earrings

Diamond Studs

The most versatile jewelry gift. Perfect for every occasion and pair beautifully with anything.

Starting from $176

Shop Studs →
Diamond earrings

Diamond Earrings

From elegant hoops to dramatic drops, diamond earrings make an unforgettable gift.

Starting from $183

Shop Earrings →
Diamond pendant

Diamond Pendants

A timeless gift she will wear every day. Choose from solitaires, hearts, and designer styles.

Starting from $492

Shop Pendants →
Diamond ring

Diamond Rings

Anniversary bands, fashion rings, and milestone pieces that mark a moment forever.

Starting from $465

Shop Rings →
Tennis bracelet

Tennis Bracelets

The ultimate luxury gift. A show-stopping piece she will treasure for a lifetime.

Starting from $1,303

Shop Bracelets →

How to Choose Jewelry Gifts Under $500

Unlock Premium Quality

Under $500, the world of fine jewelry opens wide. Diamond rings with significant center stones, tennis bracelets with continuous diamond sparkle, and diamond hoop earrings with impressive carat weights are all within reach.

Ideal for Milestone Celebrations

This is the sweet spot for anniversary gifts, engagement celebrations, and significant birthday milestones. A diamond pendant or tennis bracelet under $500 creates a lasting memory without the sticker shock.

Lab-Grown Diamond Advantage

At $500, lab-grown diamonds let you get pieces that would typically cost $800-$1,000 with natural stones. Same sparkle, same 4Cs grading, same beauty — just a smarter price.

Customization Options

Most pieces are available in 14K and 18K gold and platinum. Choose from white, yellow, or rose gold to match her preference. Want something unique? Design your own ring starting from scratch.

Beautiful jewelry gifts for every occasion and budget. Browse by price range to find the perfect present.

Under $100Under $250Under $500Under $1,000

View All Gift Ideas  |  Engagement  |  Anniversary  |  Wedding

Metal:

  • Price:

  • $
    $
Clear All
No Filters Applied
60  Items
0.28 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver PendantStyle# PQUI-QP17098TAN-SSTT
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$252
2.29 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver BraceletStyle# BQUI-QB1635TAN-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$418
1.98 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver BraceletStyle# BQUI-QB1402TAN-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$282
14K Yellow Gold Plated 0.62 Carat Genuine Tanzanite and White Topaz .925 Sterling Silver PendantStyle# PQUI-QP4007TANWT-SS14KY
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$316
14K Yellow Gold Plated 2.38 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver PendantStyle# PQUI-QP4059TAN-SS14KY
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$353
14K Yellow Gold Plated 0.84 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver PendantStyle# PQUI-QP4460TAN-SS14KY
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$307
1.33 Carat Genuine Tanzanite and White Topaz .925 Sterling Silver PendantStyle# PQUI-QP7355TANWT-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$252
1.52 Carat Genuine Tanzanite and Lab Grown Diamond .925 Sterling Silver PendantStyle# PQUI-QP17598TANLGD-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$325
1.05 Carat Genuine Tanzanite and White Topaz .925 Sterling Silver PendantStyle# PQUI-QSETP222TANWT-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$344
0.81 Carat Genuine Tanzanite and Lab Grown Diamond .925 Sterling Silver PendantStyle# PQUI-QP19988TANLGD-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$359
0.38 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver PendantStyle# PQUI-QP17084TAN-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$239
0.57 Carat Genuine Tanzanite and Lab Grown Diamond .925 Sterling Silver PendantStyle# PQUI-QP12645TANLGD-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$295
0.18 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver PendantStyle# PQUI-QP3998TAN-SSTT
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$202
1.93 Carat Genuine Tanzanite and White Topaz .925 Sterling Silver PendantStyle# PQUI-QP6776TANWT-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$341
1.99 Carat Genuine Tanzanite and White Zircon .925 Sterling Silver PendantStyle# PQUI-QP6776TANWZ-SSRPLT
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$445
1.15 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver PendantStyle# PQUI-QP2754TAN-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$378
1.75 Carat Genuine Tanzanite and White Zircon .925 Sterling Silver PendantStyle# PQUI-QP11519TANWZ-SSTT
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$310
0.84 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver PendantStyle# PQUI-QP4460TAN-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$199
3.78 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver PendantStyle# PQUI-QP16272TAN-SSPP
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$390
2.64 Carat Genuine Tanzanite and White Topaz .925 Sterling Silver PendantStyle# PQUI-QP2713TANWT-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$350
2.00 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver PendantStyle# PQUI-QP4186TAN-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$295
2.23 Carat Genuine Tanzanite and White Zircon .925 Sterling Silver PendantStyle# PQUI-QP6115TANWZ-BDIP
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$356
0.75 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver PendantStyle# PQUI-QP1600TAN-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$122
0.10 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver PendantStyle# PQUI-QP17099TAN-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$335
0.97 Carat Genuine Tanzanite and Lab Grown Diamond .925 Sterling Silver RingStyle# RQUI-QR41101TANLGD-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$304
1.05 Carat Genuine Tanzanite and White Topaz .925 Sterling Silver RingStyle# RQUI-QSETR222TANWT-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$350
1.02 Carat Genuine Tanzanite and White Topaz .925 Sterling Silver RingStyle# RQUI-QSETR259TANWT-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$368
3.78 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver BraceletStyle# BQUI-QB4416TAN-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$498
3.16 Carat Genuine Tanzanite & White Topaz .925 Sterling Silver RingStyle# RQUI-QR14526TANWT-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$313
1.16 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver RingStyle# RQUI-QR761TAN-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$209
0.93 Carat Genuine Tanzanite and Lab Grown Diamond .925 Sterling Silver RingStyle# RQUI-QR41094TANLGD-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$372
2.29 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver BraceletStyle# BQUI-QB1635TAN-SS14KY
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$399
1.30 Carat Genuine Tanzanite and White Topaz .925 Sterling Silver BraceletStyle# BQUI-QB1196TANWT-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$261
0.45 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver PendantStyle# PQUI-QP17103TAN-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$304
3.75 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver RingStyle# RQUI-QR13610TAN-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$347
4.59 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver BraceletStyle# BQUI-QB168TAN-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$467
0.14 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver PendantStyle# PQUI-QP17101TAN-SSTT
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$212
1.81 Carat Genuine Tanzanite and White Topaz .925 Sterling Silver BraceletStyle# BQUI-QB4147TANWT-SSTT
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$387
0.10 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver BraceletStyle# BQUI-QB4789TAN-SS18KY
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$187
1.10 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver BraceletStyle# BQUI-QB4192TAN-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$362
1.65 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver BraceletStyle# BQUI-QB4123TAN-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$261
0.56 Carat Genuine Tanzanite and Lab Grown Diamond .925 Sterling Silver RingStyle# RQUI-QR37004TANLGD-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$270
0.50 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver BraceletStyle# BQUI-QB4124TAN-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$181
0.77 Carat Genuine Tanzanite and White Sapphire .925 Sterling Silver BraceletStyle# BQUI-QB4145TANWSAPH-SSTT
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$356
0.91 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver BraceletStyle# BQUI-QB4195TAN-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$267
0.11 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver PendantStyle# PQUI-QP3997TAN-SSTT
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$184
3.96 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver RingStyle# RQUI-QR5643TAN-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$316
3.08 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver BraceletStyle# BQUI-QB169TAN-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$387
1.56 Carat Genuine Tanzanite and White Diamond .925 Sterling Silver BraceletStyle# BQUI-QB4198TANWD-SS18KY
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$427
0.84 Carat Genuine Tanzanite and Lab Grown Diamond .925 Sterling Silver RingStyle# RQUI-QR41095TANLGD-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$329
0.87 Carat Genuine Tanzanite and White Topaz .925 Sterling Silver RingStyle# RQUI-QSETR221TANWT-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$356
1.05 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver ringStyle# RQUI-QR21171TAN-B-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$270
0.69 Carat Genuine Tanzanite and Lab Grown Diamond .925 Sterling Silver RingStyle# RQUI-QR41117TANLGD-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$276
1.51 Carat Genuine Tanzanite and White Topaz .925 Sterling Silver ringStyle# RQUI-QR23371TANWT-B-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$329
1.03 Carat Genuine Tanzanite and Lab Grown Diamond .925 Sterling Silver RingStyle# RQUI-QR38816TANLGD-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$458
2.24 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver EarringsStyle# EQUI-QE5326TAN-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$202
0.90 Carat Genuine Tanzanite and Lab Grown Diamond .925 Sterling Silver RingStyle# RQUI-QR41100TANLGD-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$338
4.74 Carat Genuine Tanzanite .925 Sterling Silver EarringsStyle# EQUI-QE1772TAN-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$301
0.56 Carat Genuine Tanzanite and Lab Grown Diamond .925 Sterling Silver RingStyle# RQUI-QR41158TANLGD-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$245
0.87 Carat Genuine Tanzanite and Lab Grown Diamond .925 Sterling Silver RingStyle# RQUI-QR41097TANLGD-SSR
  • Sterling Silver
    SS
$350

Real Customers, Real Reviews

What Our Customers Say

★★★★★ 5.0 · 222+ Five-Star Google Reviews
★★★★★

“My now fiance decided to work with Deep and Dave to custom make my engagement ring — which is 100% perfect. They do incredible work and the ring exceeded all expectations.”

Casey O. via Google
★★★★★

“USA Jewels is a hidden gem! The custom ring I designed turned out incredible. Fair prices and unmatched quality. My fiancee was blown away.”

Trevor G. via Google
★★★★★

“They made the process so easy and stress-free. They answered all my questions and helped me find the perfect ring within my budget. Highly recommend!”

Ashley P. via Google
Mother receiving a jewelry gift

Give Something Meaningful

A Gift She Will Treasure Forever

Whether it is her birthday, your anniversary, a holiday surprise, or simply a moment to say I love you — jewelry speaks louder than words. Each piece from USA Jewels is handcrafted by our family of jewelers in Deerfield Beach, Florida, and arrives in elegant gift-ready packaging with free insured shipping.

Browse Gifts Get Gift Recommendations

Explore More

Continue Shopping

Gifts Under $100 Browse gifts under $100
Browse →
Gifts Under $250 Browse gifts under $250
Browse →
Gifts Under $1,000 Browse gifts under $1,000
Browse →
All Gift Ideas Browse the full gift collection
Browse →
Engagement Rings Solitaires, halos & three-stone
Browse →
Lab-Grown Diamonds Same sparkle, up to 50% less
Browse →
Gemstone Jewelry Rubies, sapphires & emeralds
Browse →
Diamond Education Learn about the 4Cs
Browse →
Contact Us Talk to a jewelry expert
Browse →

Common Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the best jewelry gifts under $500?
Diamond rings, tennis bracelets, diamond hoop earrings, and solitaire pendants with larger center stones are the most impactful gifts in this range. These are pieces she will wear for years.
Can I get an engagement ring under $500?
Yes. We offer beautiful solitaire and halo engagement rings under $500, especially with lab-grown diamonds. Visit our engagement ring collection for the full selection.
What carat weight can I expect under $500?
With natural diamonds, expect 0.25-0.50 carat total weight for rings and pendants, and higher for accent pieces like studs. With lab-grown diamonds, you can get 0.50-1.0 carat for the same budget.
Do you offer payment plans?
We accept all major credit cards. For larger purchases, check with your credit card provider about their installment options. Every order includes free insured shipping.
Can I customize the metal type?
Yes. Most pieces are available in 14K and 18K gold (white, yellow, rose) and platinum. Select your preferred metal during checkout, or contact us for custom requests.
What is your return policy?
We offer a 30-day money-back guarantee on all purchases. If she would prefer a different style, size, or metal, we handle exchanges at no extra cost.

Need Help Choosing a Gift?

Our jewelry experts have helped thousands of customers find the perfect gift. Call, email, or visit our showroom.

Call (877) 872-9909 Contact Us